A post-holiday analysis released this week by local researchers confirmed that the overwhelming majority of “thoughtful, handmade gifts” exchanged across Pinellas County this Christmas were not the result of deep personal insight, but rather financial distress combined with a limited understanding of the recipient as a person.

The study, conducted using regional spending data, Etsy browser histories, and a disturbing surplus of mason jars, found that nearly 8 out of 10 handmade gifts were produced by residents with less than $50 in their checking accounts and only a loose, theoretical relationship to the person receiving the gift.

“These gifts are often framed as meaningful and intentional,” said Clearwater-based consumer analyst Dana Holbrook. “But when you look closer, you’re really seeing someone who couldn’t afford Tyrone Mall and panicked around December 22.”

According to the report, common indicators of a “financially motivated handmade gift” included phrases like “I thought this would suit you,” “it’s more about the meaning,” and “I didn’t know what to get you,” all of which appeared frequently during exchanges involving homemade candles, baked goods wrapped in twine, and wall art featuring inspirational quotes chosen primarily because they were easy to stencil.

Pinellas residents interviewed after the holiday described a familiar pattern.

“My neighbor gave me a jar of beach-themed potpourri,” said Seminole resident Lisa Carter. “I hate scented things, I don’t decorate coastal, and we’ve never spoken longer than 90 seconds. But she kept saying how personal it was.”

Others reported receiving hand-made candles labeled with vague affirmations, and framed song lyrics from artists the recipient does not listen to and has never mentioned.

Researchers noted that many gift-givers appeared genuinely surprised when recipients did not react with visible emotion.

“They’ll watch you open it like they’ve handed you a piece of their soul,” Holbrook said. “Meanwhile, you’re holding a soy candle that smells like ‘Florida Rain’ and trying to decide which closet it’s going to disappear into.”

When interviewed anonymously, many handmade gift-givers admitted the reality.

“I had $14 and three coworkers,” said one St. Pete respondent. “I don’t really know them, but I know how to use a glue gun.”

The report also found that handmade gifts were most commonly exchanged among extended family members, coworkers, and people who say things like “we should hang out more” but never do.

‍